Storage Devices

 
 
Sources:
A great source of drives, storage, RAID and related devices is LaCie. State-of-the-art products, LaCie is the first place to look and might be the best place to buy. </ED>
 
Other outstanding sources include Adaptec, Small Dog, PowerMax and a host of other vendors listed on nCity's Links Page (above). Local Sacramento area retail outlets include BestBuy, CompUSA and Fry's. The Grass Valley Staples _might_ have a hard drive or two, along with most peripherals.
 
 
External Links:
LaCie All types of drives
Adaptec PCI cards, RAID, storage
Small Dog
Fry's Outpost (online store only)
Best Buy Good prices
SCSI Source
NewEgg GREAT prices!
Staples Local
Selecting storage devices:
As noted on the Support Page, there are a variety of things that can (and do) go wrong with storage devices of all kinds. From physical damage and crashed heads, to mangled directories, fragmentation and errors indicating the volume is not recognized or cannot mount. Or worse: no error message, no startup - only a strange noise.
 
The dialog box shown (right) is what greets you when a new, unformatted disk is connected; it is also what appears when a severely damaged volume refuses to mount. (Initialize = erase.)
 
Whether you are replacing a drive or adding to your system, a lot of trouble (and expense) can be avoided by carefully choosing the best device for the job, according to port/bus type and connection (SCSI, IDE/ATA, SATA, ethernet), storage capacity and speed, installation and intended use. (Also see below.)
 
You should also be aware of any limitations that may be imposed by Operating System and/or machine's CPU, make/model. For example, the Quicksilver and earlier Macs may have a "theoretical maximum" volume capacity of 128GB, which means it does not have "large drive" support for HDDs over 128GB (even if partitioned). Notebook machines have even more stringent requirements and specs.
 
Connector types:
  • USB: The slowest port option, but easiest to use - USB replaced ADB (keyboard and mouse) and serial ports for connecting printers and gadgets of all types. It would be my last choice for storage in amounts greater than 600MB or so (CD), but it's relatively slow transfer rate may not be a factor if used for automated (off hours) backup purposes.
  • IDE/ATA (Parallel): Large, fast, cheap - choice of most manufacturers these days for OEM drives in desktops and laptops; only choice for replacing HDs in iMacs and laptops. The ATA bus also handles CD or DVD and other internal drives in most Macs. PowerMac G4s and G5s (towers and some desktops) have 2 internal IDE busses capable of handling two devices each, but these must be properly configured using jumpers (photos, right).
  • Serial ATA (SATA): Starting with the G5, serial ATA drives are used internally and may be an external option with proper PCI card installed or an available SATA port. These have the advantage of not needing configuration (no jumpers) and are priced about the same as conventional IDE/ATA drives.
  • Firewire (aka, IEEE-1394 A/B): Camera buffs, audiophiles and editors tend to look for Firewire devices (where speed and large file transfers are major concerns). FireWire has become the protocol of choice for external drives and high-end devices of all kinds. Best choice for external backup, with terrabyte drives available and excellent speed. FireWire ports have been standard equipment on Macs for quite awhile, and may be added to older Macs with an available PCI slot. FireWire devices can be daisy chained.
  • SCSI (Small Computer Systems Interface [pronounced "scuzzy"]): Fastest (and still the champ!) for internal and external hard drives and devices. Best choice for servers, RAID (Redundant Array of Independent Disks), and intensive editing/storage, especially AV. SCSI devices require configuration, termination adjustments, and an assigned address when connecting to a SCSI chain. SCSI was standard equipment on Macs for many years.....
Initialize Options
MFS? HFS? HFS+? UFS? ProDOS? IDE/ATA? SATA? SCSI?
Whatever it is, it's either new (unformatted) or DOA. 
 
FireWire Logo
Apple's FireWire name and logo is adopted industry standard for technology that might otherwise be known as "IEEE-1394."
Which name would you rather use?
 
 
Drive Jumpers
Jumpers are used to configure ATA drives.
 
 
Pile o'PCIs
PCI cards fit towers and add expansion ports.
 
 
Ribbon Cables
Ribbon and power cables for connecting internal devices.
 
 
 
Storage capacity and speed:
 
USB:
USB offers some high capacity options, but speed may be a limiting factor in applications requiring data streams.
 
IDE/ATA/SerialATA:
These deliver the lowest price option with reasonable speed and capacity. Perfectly suited to most users as both primary and backup drives. Serious power users might face limitations due to attached devices (2 per bus for ATA) and might prefer faster/larger SATA or SCSI.
 
Firewire drives:
Using a FireWire bridgeboard provides the best of all worlds. High capacity, high speed, reasonable cost, compatibility and convenience.
 
SCSI:
The most expensive option by far, has the advantage of speed, internal and/or external installation, and connection of multiple devices on one terminated bus. Older Macs were exclusively SCSI; newer machines require addition of a PCI card matched to the drive(s) being installed. (SCSI is not an option for iMacs.)
 
Comparison Chart:
 
Device Chart
 
Installation:
Internal devices use standardized power + cable connections and require a mounting bay. Proper installation may include fastening the device to a drive "sled" (or tray) designed to slide into a mounting bay - most internal drives are mounted in this fashion. PowerMacs are built with extra bays and PCI slots, wired for expansion (not an option for iMacs).
 
Laptops use miniature, model-specific drives, available in assorted capacities as aftermarket upgrades and/or build-to-order options. Do-it-yourself installation/upgrades of laptop models is not recommended.
 
External devices - primarily USB and FireWire - do not require much beyond a port; likewise the new Serial IDE (w/card). SCSI requires an address and termination on/off (usually via switches), and a SCSI port (older Macs) or optional PCI card (newer models), most of which have both internal and external SCSI ports.
 
USB, FireWire and Serial IDE devices are generally "plug-and-play" provided they have ports available and/or proper PCI cards installed. SCSI and IDE/ATA devices require configuration; SCSI can be especially finicky.
 
 
 
Drive Preparation Notes:
All hard drives must be formatted prior to use. Some drives come pre formatted and/or include software disk utilities. Most drives can be formatted using OS-appropriate Apple utilities, but others might not be recognized, making a third-party utility such as LaCie's Silverlining necessary.
 
Drives must also be configured for installation: ATA/IDE drives are installed on a two-device bus in "master-slave" configuration or in "cable select" mode. SCSI devices are mechanically assigned a number (by switch or jumper) with a maximum of seven devices on a bus, including the CPU (which is always #7). SCSI busses must also be terminated. USB, FireWire and Serial ATA are the newest and easiest types to install, requiring little or no configuration.

 
Drive failure and recovery services:
See "Volume Recovery" in Services section (above).

N_City Logo

nCity Home..........Solutions...........Support..........Services..........Courses..........Links..........nCity Forum